The reviews most companies hide

Every 1 & 2 star review we've ever received.

1,023 five-star reviews. 4.92 average. And exactly 6 reviews under 3 stars in 20 years. Most companies bury them. We publish all of them — with our honest, detailed response to each.

Critical review #1

"Got 12 calls in my first week and closed zero. This system is broken — the people calling don't actually want to buy."

Greg P.

New agent, 4 months licensed

Our response

We pulled Greg's call recordings. Of his 12 calls, 9 were answered after the 6th ring, 2 went to voicemail, and the average talk time was 1m 14s.

Our network-wide data shows a 1-in-3 close rate when the call is answered inside two rings and the conversation lasts at least 4 minutes.

Greg's profile flagged that he had 4 months of licensed experience and zero closed final-expense policies. Our 'Not Built For' section on the homepage specifically calls out brand-new agents — we should have caught this during onboarding, and we've since tightened that filter.

Bottom line: the calls were real buyers. The agent was not yet ready to handle them. We refunded Greg's setup fee in full.

Critical review #2

"Total scam. They charge you and then you never get calls."

Anonymous

Did not provide license or agency info

Our response

This review was left without a verifiable account, license number, or agency on file. We searched every email and phone number associated with our last 24 months of accounts — no match.

Every applicant submits a state license before we route a single call. Every account has a real-time call log the agent can audit themselves.

We left this review up because we don't believe in hiding criticism, but we want to be honest with prospective agents: we have no evidence this person was ever a customer.

Critical review #3

"The calls are good but I'm getting too many of them — I can't keep up and my close rate dropped to 18%."

Linda M.

Medicare agent, MI

Our response

Linda is right that her close rate dropped. That's a volume-cap problem, not a quality problem.

Every agent in our network can set a daily call cap inside their dashboard. Linda's cap was set to 'unlimited' for the first 60 days at her request.

We've since added a default cap of 15 calls/day for new agents and a soft-warning when close rate dips below 25%. Linda is back at 31% close after capping at 12/day.

Honest take: this is real feedback that made our product better. We'd give ourselves a 2-star for the onboarding gap, too.

Critical review #4

"I expected the billboards to be in Manhattan. They're on rural highways. False advertising."

Robert K.

Independent broker, NY

Our response

We have never claimed our billboards are in Manhattan. Our coverage page lists all 50 states with exact counts — New York has 2 billboards, both placed on Interstate corridors where drive-time and call-back rates are highest.

Urban billboards convert at roughly 1/4 the rate of highway billboards for insurance calls. We've tested this for 20 years. Highway commuters call. City pedestrians don't.

If Robert wants Manhattan eyeballs, we are not the right network. Our entire model is highway traffic — that's why our close rates exist.

Critical review #5

"Half the people calling don't even speak English. Unusable."

Cindy B.

Final expense agent, AL

Our response

Roughly 18% of inbound calls in our southern markets are Spanish-speaking, which matches the demographic of who is actually buying final-expense in those zip codes.

Our dashboard has a language filter. Cindy never enabled it. Once she did (with our support team on the phone), she stopped receiving Spanish calls and her close rate rose to 29%.

We left her review at 1 star because that's what she gave us. We're not editing reviews. But the tool to fix it existed from day one.

Critical review #6

"The calls are fine but I don't like that the leads aren't exclusive to me state-wide."

Marcus D.

Life insurance agent, OK

Our response

Calls are exclusive per-call: when a person dials the number, exactly one agent's phone rings. There is no list resold to five buyers.

What is shared is the geography — multiple agents can serve the same state, because 1 agent cannot answer the call volume of 9 billboards in Texas.

If state-wide exclusivity is the requirement, the math doesn't work for us or for the agent. We'd rather be honest about this upfront than oversell.

4.92 / 5
From 1,023 verified five-star agent reviews

Now the 1,023 five-star ones.

A sample of what agents say after their first 90 days on CallMediaGroup.

"Closed 3 policies in my first week. Callers already know what they want — I just write the policy."


Marcus T.

Insurance Agent, TX

"After years of dialing dead numbers, having buyers call ME feels like cheating."


Jennifer R.

Senior Market Specialist, FL

"A lady called in already knowing her plan. Eight minute call, signed deal."


David M.

Independent Agent, OH

"I cancelled my $4k/mo lead vendor the day I switched. Not going back."


Priya S.

Final Expense, GA

"Close rate jumped from 6% on cold dials to 34% on these inbounds. The math is wild."


Tony R.

Medicare Agent, AZ

"Honestly the billboards do the convincing. They're sold on calling before they call."


Brittany L.

Life & Health, NC

"Three years in. Built a six-figure book without dialing a single number."


Hector V.

Agency Owner, CA

"The volume scales with how many hours I want to work. That's the whole pitch."


Sarah K.

Broker, PA

"Best money I've ever spent on producing calls. Period."


Eli W.

Medicare Agent, MO

"I work 4 hours a day and outproduce agents grinding 10. Inbounds are different."


Renee P.

Final Expense, SC

"Onboarded 6 producers on CallMediaGroup calls. All 6 still here a year later."


James O.

Agency Owner, IL

"I trust the call quality enough that I quit my W-2 last spring. No regrets."


Carla H.

Life Agent, NV